How We Review & Rate Online Casinos

Home » How We Review & Rate Online Casinos

How We Review & Rate Online Casinos

At SafeGamingSites.com, our first priority is player safety.
Online gambling involves real money and can affect your finances and wellbeing, so we treat every review as a serious responsibility – not just a list of bonuses.

This page explains, in plain language, how we test, review, and rate online casinos before we recommend them anywhere on our site.

Our Review Principles

Every casino review on SafeGamingSites.com follows a few simple rules:

Player-first, safety-first
We put safety, licensing, and fair treatment of players ahead of promotions or commissions. If a casino looks risky, we don’t recommend it.
Independent judgement
We are not a casino and we do not operate any gambling site. We may earn a commission if you sign up through our links, but casinos cannot buy a positive rating or “top spot” on our lists. For a full explanation of how commissions work, see our Advertising & Affiliate Disclosure.
Real testing where possible
We aim to register, deposit, play, and withdraw at the casinos we feature, so our reviews reflect real experiences, not just marketing claims.
Local relevance
Our main focus is casinos that accept players from Malaysia and Singapore, but the same core review standards apply to every brand we list.

Responsible gambling
We promote legal, age-restricted, and responsible gambling only. We do not encourage chasing losses or treating gambling as a way to make money.

How Our Rating System Works

Every casino we review receives:

An overall SafeGaming rating out of 10
An internal risk level (from “low risk / trusted” to “high risk / not recommended”)
In some cases, a “Verified” badge if it meets our stricter standards

We base the overall rating on a set of scored categories, with safety and payments weighted higher than bonuses or design.

Approximate weightings:

Safety, Licensing & Player Protection – 30%
Payments & Banking – 20%
Fair Play, Terms & Reputation – 15%
Games & Software – 10%
Bonuses & Real Value – 10%
User Experience & Mobile – 10%
Customer Support – 5%

We care most about whether a casino is safe, licensed, and paying out players properly. A good-looking site with poor terms or slow payments will score badly, even if the games are fun.

Rating Bands (Internal)

We use these internal bands to guide our recommendations:

9.0 – 10.0: Trusted & Recommended
Strong performance across safety, payments, and fairness. May qualify as a “Verified” casino.
7.0 – 8.9: Generally Good, Some Points to Check
Suitable for most players, but there may be terms, limits, or features you should read carefully in our review.
5.0 – 6.9: Mixed or Higher-Risk
We highlight serious drawbacks (for example: slow withdrawals, weak licensing, or poor complaints history). We may not list these casinos on our “best” pages.

Below 5.0: Not Recommended
We do not promote these casinos and may include them on warning / “avoid” lists instead.

What We Check: Our Core Review Criteria

1. Safety, Licensing & Player Protection (≈30%)

This is always our starting point.

We check:

Valid gambling licences
The casino should hold a licence from a recognised regulator and display it clearly on the site. We verify licence details where possible.
Security & encryption
The website must use HTTPS and modern encryption (e.g. SSL/TLS) to protect personal and payment data.
Ownership & track record
We look at who owns the casino, how long it has operated, and whether the company has a history of fair or unfair behaviour.
Responsible gambling tools
We check whether players can set deposit limits, loss limits, time limits, or self-exclude, and whether the casino links to support organisations.

If a casino fails basic safety or licensing checks, we do not recommend it, no matter how attractive the bonuses look.

2. Fair Play, Terms & Complaint History (≈15%)

A casino can be licensed and still treat players unfairly through bad terms or bad behaviour. We therefore:

Read the Terms & Conditions and bonus rules, focusing on:
- Wagering requirements
- Maximum win or payout limits
- Restricted games and countries
- Dormant account rules and fees
Look for unfair or predatory clauses, such as vague reasons to confiscate winnings or unusual identification demands at withdrawal stage.
Review complaints and player feedback
We consider both complaints sent directly to SafeGamingSites.com and credible third-party sources.

When we see patterns of:

Non-payment or long-term delayed payments
Repeated bonus confiscations without clear reason
Aggressive use of terms against ordinary players

we lower the rating and, in serious cases, stop recommending the casino altogether.

3. Payments & Banking (≈20%)

Payments can make or break the player experience. For each casino we assess:

Deposit and withdrawal methods
Bank transfers, e-wallets, cards, local payment options, and (where applicable) crypto. For our core regions we pay special attention to Malaysian and Singaporean banking options.
Processing speeds
How long it usually takes to receive your money after a successful withdrawal request. We look for consistent, timely payouts.
Minimum and maximum limits
Reasonable minimum deposit amounts and clear withdrawal limits, per transaction and per day/week/month.
Fees & currency support
Whether the casino charges extra fees, and whether common regional currencies are supported.

Whenever possible, we test deposits and withdrawals ourselves to confirm that the process is clear, secure, and reasonably fast.

4. Games, Software & Live Casino (≈10%)

We want players to have access to:

Reputable software providers
We prefer casinos that work with well-known, properly licensed game studios.
Variety of games
Slots, live casino, table games, and – where relevant – sportsbook, esports, and lottery options.
Game fairness
We look for independent testing or certificates that show games use proper Random Number Generators (RNGs) and fair rules.

We do not recommend casinos that rely heavily on unknown, untested, or suspicious game providers without clear information.

5. Bonuses & Real Value (≈10%)

Bonuses and promotions can be helpful, but they are never more important than safety or fair terms.

We check:

Welcome bonuses – size, match percentage, real wagering requirements, and any hidden conditions.
Ongoing offers – reloads, cashback, VIP programs, tournaments, and loyalty schemes.
Transparency – whether all key rules are easy to find and written in clear language.

We favour casinos with fair, realistic conditions, not just the biggest advertised numbers. High bonuses with impossible requirements will score poorly.

6. User Experience & Mobile (≈10%)

We want casinos to be:

Easy to navigate – finding games, promotions, and support should be straightforward.
Stable and fast – pages should load reasonably quickly without constant errors.
Mobile-friendly – the website should work well on smartphones and tablets; dedicated mobile apps are a plus but not required.

We test how the site feels on both desktop and mobile, and we note any serious usability problems in our review.

7. Customer Support (≈5%)

Even at the best casinos, you may need help.

We check:

Support channels – live chat, email, social media, messaging apps, or phone.
Opening hours – 24/7 support is ideal, especially for markets where players are active outside office hours.
Response quality – how quickly and how clearly support answers basic questions.

We test support with simple, realistic questions (for example about withdrawals or bonuses) and factor the experience into the score.

8. Local Fit (Regional Criteria)

While this page explains our global approach, some points matter more in specific countries or regions.

For example, for Malaysia and Singapore we place extra weight on:

Local payment options and bank handling
Language and currency support
How the casino deals with players from these regions in practice
Any region-specific risks or complaints

Our country and regional criteria pages build on this global policy and explain the local details in more depth, including our Verified Online Casino Malaysia criteria and our online casino criteria for Singapore.

How We Test Casinos: Step-by-Step

Where possible, our team follows a simple, repeatable process for every casino:

Background check
- Confirm licensing and ownership details
- Check security (HTTPS/SSL), privacy policy, and responsible gambling information
Account creation
- Register an account and note any unusual sign-up requirements
KYC / verification experience
- Where required, submit documents and review how the casino handles identity checks
Deposit & play
- Make a real-money deposit using common payment methods
- Play a selection of games to see performance, stability, and general experience
Withdrawal test
- Request a withdrawal and track how long it takes, what documents are requested, and whether there are any unexpected limits or issues
Customer support test
- Contact support through at least one channel with realistic questions (for example: “How long do withdrawals take?”)
Review terms again
- Re-check terms and bonus rules based on our test experience and any red flags that appeared during play
Assign rating & verdict
- Score each category, calculate the overall SafeGaming rating, and write an honest summary of strengths and weaknesses

We update this process over time as the industry and player needs change.

Transparency & Affiliate Disclosure

To keep SafeGamingSites.com free to use, we sometimes receive a commission when you create an account or make a deposit through our links.

However:

We do not accept payment to change our ratings, hide serious problems, or list casinos we believe are unsafe.
We are transparent when a casino has serious issues and we will warn you clearly in the review.
If a casino’s behaviour changes, our rating and recommendations can change too.

Our goal is simple: help you avoid bad casinos and find safer, more reliable options, using a clear, consistent review system you can understand and trust.